Book Review
Agatha Oddly: The Secret Key
Pages: 325

Description of Book / Brief Plot Summary:
Agatha Oddly is a 13 year old girl living in a house in Hyde Park, London with her father who the head gardener. She loves being a detective and in this book her first real case comes along. With her friend Liam, she investigates a strange red algae that is polluting London’s water supply, encountering a secret society along the way and learning more about her mother who died when she was young.
From the cover: Meet thirteen-year-old Agatha Oddly – a bold, determined heroine, and the star of a stylish new detective series. Agatha Oddlow has been a detective for as long as she can remember – she’s just been waiting for her first big case. And nothing gets bigger than saving the City of London from some strange goings-on. With a scholarship to the prestigious St Regis School, a cottage in the middle of Hyde Park, a room full of beloved sleuthing novels, and a secret key that gives her access to a whole hidden side of London, Agatha is perfectly poised to solve the mystery of what’s going on. But just who can she trust when no one is quite who they seem…
Language – Does the book contain any offensive or blasphemous language?
The book contains two blasphemies – ‘Mon Dieu’ and ‘Bejeezus’. One chapter is called ‘A Vision of the Damned’ which refers to an unpleasant, although not graphic location the protagonists visit.
Religious Content – Does the book contain any religious content, Christian or other?
None.
Moral Content – Good and Bad. Does the book contain any positive moral content? Does the book contain any questionable themes?
As is often the case with children detective stories, there is an element of deceit involved (although in a good cause). Agatha also skips school quite often.
Agatha is a bit of a misfit at her prestigious private school. The book subtly emphasises the importance of not bowing to peer pressure and of strong friendships.
Other Comments:
Unsurprisingly, the premise and plot are very unrealistic. Some of the subject matter – kidnap, peril etc make this a book more for older children.
The book makes quite a bit of reference to Agatha Christie characters such as Hercule Poirot who features as a figment of Agatha’s imagination advising her.
It is the first book in a series. The reviewed copy was published in 2018.

